Flight of the Earls

Itinerary of the earls

On 14 September 1607, Irish earls Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone, and Rory O'Donnell, 1st Earl of Tyrconnell, permanently departed Rathmullan in Ireland for mainland Europe, accompanied by their families, household staff, followers and fellow nobility, numbering about ninety people. The earls were patriarchs of the two most powerful clans in Ulster (the O'Neill and O'Donnell clans), and their permanent exile is seen to symbolise the end of Gaelic Irish society.[1] This event is now known as the Flight of the Earls (Irish: Imeacht na nIarlaí).

Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone, (left) and Rory O'Donnell, 1st Earl of Tyrconnell

Both earls fought against the English Crown in the Nine Years' War, which ended with their surrender in 1603. Although the earls managed to retain their lands and titles, hostility towards them from English politicians gradually increased over time. The flight was seemingly a snap decision;[2] its exact motivation is unclear and is the subject of debate.[3] They may have been conspiring against the government, and their flight could have been an attempt to evade arrest.[4] The earls intended to reach Habsburg Spain, which had allied with the Irish confederacy during the war, but were turned away by Philip III for fear of violating the recent Treaty of London.[5] The refugees spent time in Leuven in the Spanish Netherlands, where many of the passengers left their young children to be educated at the Irish College of St Anthony. The earls arrived in Rome on 29 April 1608 and were granted small pensions by Pope Paul V. Their accommodation in Rome was paltry compared to their estates in Ireland. Tyrconnell died of a fever three months later. Tyrone repeatedly discussed plans to return to Ireland and retake his lands, but he became ill and died in 1616 before doing so. Most of the passengers on the flight never returned to Ireland. The flight was declared as treasonous by James VI and I and the earls' titles were forefeited, which led to the acquisition of the earls' lands as part of the Plantation of Ulster.

  1. ^ Ó Ciardha 2007.
  2. ^ Morgan 2014.
  3. ^ Bagwell 1895, p. 445. "The immediate cause of their sudden departure may be doubtful, but not the real causes."; Smith 1996, pp. 17–20. "One of the most argued over events in the career of Hugh O'Neill, second Earl of Tyrone, is his departure from Ireland..."; Walsh 1996, p. 9. "The factors which induced O Neill to leave Ireland in 1607 have always been a matter of controversy among historians."; McGurk 2007, p. 18. "O'Neill's decision to leave Ireland has puzzled contemporaries and successive generations of historians..."; Morgan 2014. "There is no satisfactory explanation for the panicked flight of Hugh O'Neill..."
  4. ^ McGurk 2007, p. 20. "Historians have been unable to agree on whether or not there was a plot in 1607... Those who affirm its existence conclude that the earls were in fact fleeing for their very lives... On whether there was a government plot against O'Neill's life the historical jury is still out".; Smith 1996, pp. 17–20. "Their allegation that there was an official plot against O'Neill is still in question. However they were certainly wrong in claiming that O'Neill was innocent of plotting himself..."; Bagwell 1895, p. 445. "So far as Tyrconnel was concerned there can be no doubt that he had been in correspondence with Spain, but it must remain uncertain whether there was any conspiracy."; Ó Cianáin 1916, p. x. "...there is no evidence of conspiracy on the part of O Néill or Maguidhir."
  5. ^ McGurk 2007, pp. 20–21; Walsh 1996, p. 72.

© MMXXIII Rich X Search. We shall prevail. All rights reserved. Rich X Search